Testimonials

"Caitlin is a phenomenal piercer and offers the best jewelry selection in the area. She has done five of my piercings so far, tapered open my first lobes and pierced my daughter’s first lobes. Her attention to detail and mindfulness about creating a clean, safe, friendly environment is unparalleled. I have had some pretty thick cartilage pierced and Caitlin was swift with the piercing and jewelry transfer, minimizing pain and discomfort like the absolute pro she is. Highly recommend her ear curation service if you have multiple piercings planned, either at once or over time, or are undecided about your piercing/jewelry options. I will be back many times over!"

"I received a permanent bracelet from Katie and had such a delightful experience in Holier Toledo. She explained the process to me very clearly and presented so many options for chains and charms! Katie radiates genuine joy and is very easy to talk to. She is a breath of fresh air in the industry. Instead of feeling like a customer, I truly felt like a friend. You will not be disappointed booking permanent jewelry with Katie. I also found out she is on track to becoming a piercer one day, too! She just fits perfectly with the Holier Toledo crew so I am excited for the knowledge and experiencrshe is going to absorb. I am so happy to be part of someone's career as early as I am. The future is so bright for her."

"My girls and I love Caitlin!!! My older two went today for second lobes and a helix. We were hoping for my youngest to get her first piercings but she was not ready. Caitlin was super patient and willing to try what we could to make her feel better but she just was not ready. The other two turned out beautifully and we will be back soon!! Thank you for an amazing experience!!!"

"I had a great time with Caitlin herself! I was treated very professionally but also like a close friend. She took the time to really explain the process so I could know what to expect at each step. Beautiful shop as you can tell a lot of time and hard work was put into it. Very comfortable place and did not feel intimidated or uncomfortable once. Thank you so much for your hospitable staff and kindness during my experience. I highly recommend Caitlin’s work!"

"This was my first time visiting Caitlin at their new location, but this was my 5th piercing (a rook this time!) completed by her or her team. I have never had a bad experience. Her personalized touch, attention to detail, and dedication to education on aftercare have kept me coming back and my first recommendation to all others looking for a piercing. The longest portion of the appointment was spent on picking out the jewelry, from which there is an enormous selection. All of my questions were quickly and honestly answered. I trust Caitlin for all my piercing and aftercare questions. From start to finish, the experience was incredible!"

"I recently had the pleasure of getting a piercing at Piercings by Caitlin in Toledo, Ohio, at her new location, and I couldn't be happier with the experience. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was welcoming and calming. Caitlin greeted me with a warm smile and took the time to explain the entire process, which made me feel comfortable and informed. Caitlin’s professionalism and attention to detail were evident throughout the procedure. She maintained a high standard of hygiene and ensured everything was sterile, which put my mind at ease. The actual piercing was quick and almost painless, thanks to her steady hands and expertise. After the piercing, Caitlin provided clear and thorough aftercare instructions, making sure I knew exactly how to take care of my new piercing. Overall, my experience at Piercings by Caitlin was fantastic, and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a safe and professional piercing experience. I will for sure be going back!"